academic-ethics

3 items

ARTICLE↑ trendingReddit r/MachineLearning·4/26/2026

How to collect evidence for LLM reviewer? [D]

A researcher received a weak rejection from a reviewer suspected of using an LLM, whose points were irrelevant and unoriginal, contrasting with positive feedback from other reviewers. The author seeks advice on how to collect evidence and report the reviewer to the academic committee for low-quality or LLM-generated feedback, considering the challenge of proving AI usage.

academic-ethics AI misuse peer review LLM

CASE↑ trendingReddit r/MachineLearning·4/8/2026

[D] Dealing with an unprofessional reviewer using fake references and personal attacks in ICML26

Um autor descreve enfrentar um avaliador extremamente antiprofissional no ICML 2026, que utilizou referências falsas, ataques pessoais e argumentos sem sentido para desqualificar seu trabalho. O autor busca orientação sobre como intervir contra um avaliador que emprega citações fraudulentas e ataques ad hominem no processo de revisão por pares.

Reviewer Misconduct academic-ethics ICML peer review

ARTICLE↑ trendingReddit r/MachineLearning·4/21/2026

[NeurIPS 2026] Will you be submitting your code alongside your submissions? [D]

This content discusses the submission of code alongside papers for NeurIPS 2026, with the author torn between the boost in credibility and concerns about plagiarism. The post seeks community opinions on this practice.

code submission academic-ethics plagiarism research integrity